Economic loss in Tort and Contracts

Authors

  • Hein Kötz
  • Letícya Simões
  • Otavio Luiz Rodrigues Junior

Keywords:

Pure economic loss, Tort liability, Contractual liability, Comparative law

Abstract

The text examines the boundaries between tort and contract in cases of economic loss, focusing on three recurring problem areas in English and German law. First, it analyzes whether damage to the defective product itself can give rise to tort liability when contractual remedies are unavailable or ineffective. It distinguishes situations where a defect merely reduces the value of the product as a whole, which remain within contract, from cases where a minor defect in a component causes disproportionate damage to an otherwise sound product, raising difficult boundary questions between contractual and tortious protection. Second, it addresses situations of “transferred loss,” in which the party who suffers the loss lacks a cause of action, while another party has a cause of action but no loss. The text compares the English refusal to extend tort liability for pure economic loss with the German solution of reallocating contractual claims through doctrines allowing recovery of third-party loss. Third, it considers liability for economic loss caused by negligent and misleading statements, showing that although English law frames liability in tort and German law often relies on contract, both systems apply similar criteria centered on reasonable reliance and foreseeability. The conclusion emphasizes that tort law traditionally protects against personal injury and physical property damage, and that expanding liability for pure economic loss requires careful limitation to avoid indeterminate liability, with both systems seeking solutions that preserve the primacy of contract rather than broadly extending tort liability.

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.

Author Biographies

Hein Kötz

Catedrático da Faculdade de Direito da Universidade de Hamburgo (Alemanha, 1981–1998). Ex-diretor do Max-Planck-Institut für ausländisches und internationales Privatrecht (Hamburgo, 1978–2000).

Letícya Simões

Bacharel em Direito (Faculdade de Direito do Largo de São Francisco) e Letras (Faculdade de Filosofia, Letras e Ciências Humanas — FFLCH) — Universidade de São Paulo.

Otavio Luiz Rodrigues Junior

Professor Titular de Direito Civil da Faculdade de Direito da Universidade de São Paulo. Docente do PPGD–Uninove. Bolsista de Pesquisa em Produtividade do CNPq (PQ 2).

Published

2026-11-17

How to Cite

KÖTZ, Hein; SIMÕES, Letícya; RODRIGUES JUNIOR, Otavio Luiz. Economic loss in Tort and Contracts. Journal of Contemporary Private Law, [S. l.], v. 48, n. 13, p. 313–325, 2026. Disponível em: https://www.ojs.direitocivilcontemporaneo.com/index.php/rdcc/article/view/1838. Acesso em: 17 nov. 2026.

Issue

Section

Doutrina Internacional